Everyone Here Is Lying: A Comprehensive Review #

Jo Piazza’s “Everyone Here Is Lying” (though the provided description suggests the title might be “Everyone Is Lying to You” based on the review link, we will proceed with the given title for this review) plunges readers into the opulent yet treacherous world of social media influencing, where curated perfection masks a deeply unsettling reality. This novel offers a thrilling exploration of secrets, ambition, and the corrosive nature of deception.

Plot Summary #

The story centers on Lizzie, who was once inseparable from her college best friend, Bex. Fifteen years prior to the events of the novel, Bex inexplicably vanished, leaving Lizzie heartbroken and bewildered. Now, Bex has reinvented herself as Rebecca Sommers, a wildly successful “traditional” Instagram influencer boasting millions of followers who are captivated by her seemingly idyllic life on a ranch with her five children and husband, Gray.

Bex, now Rebecca, re-enters Lizzie’s life with a proposition: an exclusive interview about her lucrative business venture and an invitation to “MomBomb,” a prestigious influencing conference. Lizzie accepts, but her arrival at the ranch is met with immediate chaos. Bex disappears, and her husband, Gray, is discovered brutally murdered on their sprawling property. Lizzie is thrust into a labyrinth of deceit, uncovering the dark underbelly of the influencer world, rife with jealousy, hidden affairs, swingers, and relentless backstabbing.

Overall Thoughts and Feelings #

“Everyone Here Is Lying” is a masterclass in pulpy, juicy thriller writing. Jo Piazza has crafted a narrative that is both cleverly plotted and utterly absorbing. The novel excels at creating a sense of unease and suspicion, making it difficult for the reader to trust any character or any piece of information presented. The exploration of the influencer lifestyle, with its manufactured realities and intense pressures, is particularly compelling, offering a sharp critique of a world often seen as aspirational.

Writing Style #

Piazza’s writing style is sharp, witty, and propulsive. She navigates the complexities of the influencer world with a keen eye for detail and a talent for creating vivid imagery. The language is accessible yet evocative, drawing the reader deep into the opulent settings and the psychological turmoil of the characters. There’s a distinct rhythm to her prose that keeps the pages turning, mirroring the escalating tension of the plot.

Character Development #

Character development in “Everyone Here Is Lying” is a fascinating blend of surface-level portrayal and hidden depths. Lizzie, as the outsider looking in, serves as an excellent lens through which to examine the distorted reality of Rebecca’s life. While some characters might initially appear as archetypes of the influencer world, Piazza gradually peels back layers to reveal their insecurities, motivations, and the secrets they desperately try to keep buried. Rebecca, in particular, is a complex figure, both a victim of circumstances and a master manipulator.

Literary Themes and Motifs #

Several key themes and motifs resonate throughout the novel:

• The Deception of Social Media: The most prominent theme is the stark contrast between the curated perfection presented online and the messy, often dark reality that lies beneath. The book constantly questions what is real and what is performative.
• Female Friendship and Betrayal: The fractured friendship between Lizzie and Bex is a central pillar of the story. The narrative explores the complexities of loyalty, envy, and the impact of past betrayals.
• Ambition and Its Consequences: The relentless pursuit of success and influence in the digital age is examined, highlighting the sacrifices and moral compromises characters are willing to make.
• The Hidden Lives of the Elite: The novel delves into the secrets and hidden desires of the wealthy and influential, suggesting that beneath polished exteriors, many are leading lives far removed from their public personas.

Pacing and Structure #

The pacing of “Everyone Here Is Lying” is generally excellent, maintaining a strong sense of momentum from beginning to end. The narrative shifts effectively between Lizzie’s present-day investigation and glimpses into the past, gradually building suspense. While the initial setup might feel slightly deliberate as the world and characters are introduced, once the central mystery unfolds, the plot moves at a brisk pace. There were very few moments that felt slow; instead, the intricate plotting and constant revelations kept me engaged and eager to discover what would happen next. The structure, with its dual timelines and multiple perspectives, serves to enhance the sense of mystery and misdirection.

Engagement and Interest #

The plot held my interest from the outset. The premise of a missing influencer and a murdered husband, set against the backdrop of the cutthroat social media world, is inherently captivating. The constant stream of revelations and unexpected twists ensured that I was always trying to piece together the truth, making it difficult to put the book down.

Author’s Use of Language and Imagery #

Jo Piazza’s command of language is a significant strength. She possesses a knack for crafting descriptions that are both beautiful and unsettling.

Memorable Quotes or Passages #

While specific quotes aren’t provided in the description, the overall narrative likely contains sharp observations about the influencer world and the nature of truth. The description “pulpy, juicy and cleverly plotted” itself hints at a style that prioritizes engaging storytelling and compelling characters. One can imagine passages vividly describing the opulent ranch juxtaposed with the grim reality of murder, or sharp dialogue revealing characters’ true intentions.

Emotional Impact #

“Everyone Here Is Lying” certainly evokes strong emotions. There’s a palpable sense of unease and suspicion that permeates the narrative, creating a constant state of suspense. The betrayal and manipulation at play can be frustrating and even angering, while the underlying secrets and vulnerabilities of the characters can also elicit moments of sympathy. The novel provokes deep thought about the nature of identity in the digital age and the sacrifices people make for success.

Moving or Thought-Provoking Moments #

The exploration of Lizzie’s long-standing confusion and hurt over Bex’s initial disappearance, coupled with the shocking circumstances of her reappearance and subsequent death, likely creates deeply moving moments. The revelation that “everyone is lying to you about something” is a thought-provoking concept that lingers, encouraging readers to consider the hidden truths in their own lives and the lives of those around them.

Themes and Messages Conveyed #

The author’s primary message appears to be a cautionary tale about the perils of a life built on artifice and the relentless pursuit of external validation. Piazza seems to be conveying that authenticity is a rare commodity, especially in highly public professions, and that the desire for control and perfection can lead to devastating consequences. The book succeeds in highlighting the superficiality that can define success in certain modern industries.

Social or Cultural Commentary #

The novel offers significant social and cultural commentary on the influencer industry and the broader impact of social media on society. It critiques the commodification of personal lives, the pressure to maintain an unattainable image, and the often-unseen struggles that accompany such curated existences. The book acts as a mirror to contemporary culture, reflecting on our fascination with celebrity, our desire for aspirational lifestyles, and the ethical compromises that can arise in the pursuit of fame and fortune.

Strengths and Weaknesses #

Strengths #

• Gripping Plot: The story is expertly crafted with a series of twists and turns that keep the reader guessing.
• Atmospheric Setting: The contrast between the idyllic ranch and the dark secrets creates a compelling atmosphere.
• Relevant Social Commentary: The sharp critique of the influencer world is timely and insightful.
• Engaging Writing Style: Piazza’s prose is vivid, witty, and propulsive.
• Complex Characters: Despite initial archetypes, characters reveal surprising depth and motivation.

Weaknesses #

• Potential for Over-the-Top Elements: Given the “pulpy” description, some readers might find certain plot points or character actions to be slightly exaggerated, though this can also be part of its charm.
• Reliance on Tropes: While cleverly employed, some elements of the “influencer world” narrative might tread familiar ground for readers heavily invested in this genre.

Recommendations #

I would highly recommend “Everyone Here Is Lying.” This book is perfect for readers who enjoy:

• Fast-paced thrillers with intricate plots.
• Social commentary that dissects modern cultural phenomena.
• Stories that explore the darker side of glamorous professions.
• Mysteries with a strong sense of place and atmosphere.
• Fans of authors like Liane Moriarty or Sally Rooney, who often blend domestic dramas with sharp social observation and suspense, or perhaps a darker, more cynical take on the genre than someone like Emily Giffin.

Comparison to Other Works #

Without specific knowledge of Jo Piazza’s other works or extensive comparisons within the genre readily available, it’s difficult to draw precise comparisons. However, the description suggests it sits comfortably alongside contemporary thrillers that delve into the darker aspects of relationships and societal pressures, often with a female-centric narrative. It likely shares DNA with novels that explore the psychological complexities of fame and the secrets people keep, even if the specific industry differs.

Conclusion #

“Everyone Here Is Lying” is a thrilling and insightful novel that masterfully blends suspense with sharp social commentary. Jo Piazza delivers a story that is both entertaining and thought-provoking, exposing the often-hidden realities behind curated online personas. With its compelling plot, vivid characters, and engaging writing style, this book is a must-read for anyone interested in the complexities of modern life and the secrets that lie beneath the surface.

Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Overall Impression: An explosive, expertly crafted thriller that expertly dissects the deceptive world of social media influence, leaving the reader questioning the very nature of truth and ambition.

Where to Get It #

You can find “Everyone Here Is Lying” at major online retailers and bookstores. For e-book and audiobook versions, as well as potential special offers, please check these sources:

• My Ebook
• Amazon
• Barnes & Noble
• Kobo
• Apple Books